
If you know me, then you know that my favorite band is Nine Inch Nails. In fact, I am straight up obsessed with them, hence the category this post is being filed under. Thus, last Sunday’s performance at Webster Hall, one of the final shows in the Wave Goodbye tour, which Trent Reznor claims will be the band’s last, was incredibly important to me.
I have only been listening to NIN since 2004, when I picked up The Downward Spiral via my mom’s company account with BMG music, which allowed us (for a time) to purchase select CDs for $5. It was awesome, and my CD-purchasing (or just music purchasing in general) has diminished ever since the service was pulled. I had been aware of the band since somewhere around 1998, and was familiar with mega-hits “Closer” and “Hurt,” and was re-familiarized with the latter when Johnny Cash released his even more popular cover in 2003. Sometimes, the manner in which I become interested in a piece of art or pop culture is strange and intricate, like an intertwining network of vines. In the winter of 2003, after I had once again been made aware of the band through Cash, I saw the trailer for the newest installment in my then reigning obsession: Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings adaptation. The theatrical trailer for The Two Towers featured a classic musical montage, set to a more epic version of Clint Mansell’s theme song for Requiem for a Dream. I watched the trailer over and over, and became quite fond of the song. My friend Tim, an audiophile and at the time, NIN fan, told me that the tune was actually a variation of NIN’s instrumental, “The Frail.” So I downloaded it, and liked it, although I wasn’t so sure Tim was right.
Today, I know much more background on the band, and the Requiem song, and I can safely say that it was definitely influenced by “The Frail.” They aren’t the exact same song, but Clint Mansell, the composer for Requiem, actually worked as an engineer on The Fragile, and was one of Reznor’s many protégés. The version of “The Frail” featured on the 2000 remix album Things Falling Apart replaced the soft piano chords with strings, provided by the world-famous Kronos Quartet, who also performed the score for Requiem. In that version, one can definitely hear the resemblance.
I’m drifting, I know. Half of you have probably stopped reading already. “Get to the concert review!!” you’re saying. “This guy’s a massive dork, look how much useless trivia he knows about Nine Inch Nails!!” It’s true, I know a lot. And I’m sorry if I’m taking my time, but I think it’s imperative you understand how important this band is to me. It may seem silly to some, but Reznor’s music really has touched me, and has fundamentally changed my life. It continues to today, and Sunday’s show was sort of the culmination of all that. If you’re a music lover like I am, then you understand what I’m talking about. We all have that one band, or that one song, that just speaks to us. We don’t really know why, we might even be embarrassed by it, but it’s there. It’s real. And nothing can change it.
“The Frail” was not my true introduction to Nine Inch Nails. Just as my initiation into the world of jazz was precipitated by a videogame, Grim Fandango, my intro to NIN was spurred on by a television show, one I have mentioned before on this blog, and one that no one’s ever heard of: Touching Evil. The show premiered in March 2004, right after I returned from spring break in Spain, and starred a host of talented but then unknown actors: Jeffrey Donovan, now famous for his portrayal of super-spy Michael Westen on Burn Notice, Vera Farmiga, Kevin Durand, Zach Grenier and even Bradley Cooper. The premise of the show was a little silly: a former federal agent who’s lost all inhibitions due to a non-fatal gunshot to the head returns to help run a new division he co-founded designed to hunt down serial killers, but trust me- it was amazing.
The two-hour pilot featured Nine Inch Nail’s “A Warm Place,” which was previously used in Oliver Stone’s Natural Born Killers, and the low-fi version of “The Day the World Went Away” found on the companion disc to the band’s 2002 live album, called Still. It was also scored by Atticus Ross, a frequent NIN collaborator, who has helped mix and engineer practically all of their albums. I loved both songs and quickly downloaded them with Limewire or whatever pre-torrent program I was using back then. The Still version of TDTWWA was almost impossible to find, and I ended up with the album version, which was confusing, as it was drastically different- much louder and heavier, but the more I listened to it the more it grew on me. Eventually I decided maybe an album would be worth a listen- I had already started dipping my feet in rock music, having previously become a big fan of Pink Floyd and Radiohead. So I ordered The Downward Spiral and sat down for a listen.
At first I didn’t really like it. There was definitely songs that stuck out to me as good: “Piggy,” “Closer,” “Hurt.” But I had never heard anything quite that loud, dissonant, or jarring before. And my natural human reaction was: ugh. This is too loud. Where is the pleasant ambient music I thought I would get after watching Touching Evil? But as it was one of the few CDs I owned at the time that wasn’t jazz, I ended up listening to it constantly during my time at the New York Film Academy’s Universal Studios program in Los Angeles, and it quickly grew on me until, within mere months of first popping it into my stereo, I was obsessed. I listened to it constantly, and still have fond memories of smoking on the roof of my Burbank hotel complex, rocking out to “Ruiner” while watching wildfires burn atop the faraway hills.
I soon felt an almost addictive need for more Nine Inch Nails. So naturally I grabbed their second-most famous album, the double-disc epic The Fragile, and quickly ate it up. It took a little more time to grow on me- it was longer, and thus has more weak tracks, although I already enjoyed some songs more than those on TDS (namely “The Day the World Went Away,” “We’re In This Together” and “The Fragile.” Today, it is my favorite entry in the NIN catalogue, and the first disc is probably my most beloved piece of music ever produced. Even in July 2004 the music was inspiring me- while filming my spaghetti western I was working on a script inspired by NIN songs and structured around cues I planned to cull from TDS and The Fragile. The script has sadly been lost ever since my high school-issued Dell laptop went kaput, and it never got made, as my friends were a bunch of deadbeats and weren’t interested in helping me produce it. In the long run, it worked out: the script eventually evolved into my 28-page Intro to Dramatic and Visual Writing II project entitled Amnesiac, but as I went to Dublin and took music video production instead of Color Sync, it too never got produced. But the idea stuck with me, and it transformed into both my Advanced Television Production screenplay, called Portal (which did get produced), and an expanded one hour TV pilot of the same name. Funny how much impact a couple rock songs can have on one’s life.
I became a Nine Inch Nails fan at the perfect moment. One year after I started listening to them Trent Reznor released his newest opus, With Teeth and went on tour. In 2005 I attended my first concert, a massive show at Madison Square Garden with Queens of the Stone Age and Death From Above 1979. I have seen the band six times since then, and every time they have put on a superior show, but I’ll always have a soft spot for that first time, especially as I had just gotten into QOTSA the summer before. Reznor’s gotten very bad at picking opening acts as of late. The next show I saw had Saul Williams which was awesome. The next had Peaches, which was fun in a guilty pleasure sort of way, followed by Bauhaus, which should have been awesome except that they sounded sludgy and dissonant. Next was Does It Offend You, Yeah? which I don’t feel I need to elaborate on, and the last three shows, including the Webster Hall outing, featured the worst openers: HEALTH, Street Sweeper Social Club and The Horrors. Some of my friends like HEALTH and assure me they’re awesome, but in addition to looking like a bunch of hoodie-wearing hipsters cut out of Vibe magazine, they also put on an awful show and were almost booed off the stage. SSSC should have been cool, and they were anytime Tom Morello was doing a guitar solo, but the lead singer / rapper, Boots Riley was as terrible as his juvenile lyrics. The Horrors featured an equally douchebag-esque lead singer, who’s only capable of singing like Ian Curtis, and thus made the whole band sound like a lame rip-off of a lame-rip off of Joy Division.
But that didn’t stop the show from blowing me away. Before Reznor and co. took the stage I hadn’t exactly been in the best mood for moshing. But the second they opened with “Mr. Self Destruct” I couldn’t help myself. The rendition wasn’t quite as good as the one I had witnessed at the March 2006 show in Amherst (it’s a lot cooler when four guys are standing in a row at the front of the stage wailing on guitars), but it’s always a great opener. Next came “Piggy,” and a personal favorite of mine, “Heresy,” which is awesome live. Even when the band played the shorter, album version of “March of the Pigs” and segued right into “Closer,” I still didn’t realize what was happening. I was so overwhelmed with joy when they started “Ruiner” that it still did not occur to me. It wasn’t until “The Becoming” that it hit me: they’re playing the whole fucking album!!! And that’s when the show kind of stopped being just a concert, and transcended into a spiritual experience for me.
I wasn’t on drugs, wasn’t even drunk. But I felt high as shit. Sweat coated my body and kept getting in my eyes, but I didn’t care. The usually oppressive swell of the mosh pit now felt comforting, like I was somehow connecting with all the bald metalheads and fat chicks, like I was actually part of a community. People weren’t even moshing that much anymore- everyone was so amazed by what was happening that not even the crunching guitar riffs of “Big Man With a Gun” could get them all that riled up. We all knew we were experiencing a once in a lifetime event, something that was truly special, and would stay with us for the rest of our lives, and we knew we had to savor it.
As the band reached the quiet instrumental interlude “A Warm Place,” I found myself swaying back and forth, eyes closed, as if in ecstasy. Their music transported me to another place, a completely cerebral plane. When they finally reached the album-closer “Hurt,” people started shouting “Thank you, Trent!” I had always wanted to meet Reznor, mostly just to tell him how much his music had changed my life and because I get the feeling he’s a pretty cool guy. Tonight, I just wanted to shake his hand and say thanks for putting on such an amazing show.
After “Hurt” Trent announced that that was the first and last time the band had ever played The Downward Spiral in its entirety and in order. And if that wasn’t enough, they played another ten songs! I have to take a moment to give some props to the band’s guitarist, Robin Finck. He is fucking incredible. When I first saw NIN they had a different guitarist, Aaron North of the Icarus Line and co-founder of Buddyhead Records. He was great too, but nowhere near as awesome as Finck. Back in freshman year of college, my friend and fellow NIN-obsessive Bob Burdalski introduced me to the 2002 NIN concert DVD, And All That Could Have Been, and we both commented on how badass Finck was in it, and how we wished he was still with the band. So we were both overjoyed to hear that he was rejoining for the 2008 Lights in the Sky tour, and every subsequent show. He is amazing at the guitar. He has this great ability to take a really distinctive NIN guitar riff, and make his own, like the classic rock solo in “Ruiner.” And the things he does with feedback- astounding. Just a really, really, talented musician; he adds a whole nother level to the Nine Inch Nails live experience.
When the show was finally over I told my friend and companion Brian “that was definitely the best concert I’ve ever been too.” He wholeheartedly agreed. My ears rang for days and it took me nearly an entire week to conjure up the words to describe what I had experienced. It was the most fitting end to Nine Inch Nails I could have imagined, and I will never forget it, for as long as I live. Will this in fact be the end of NIN? I’m not so sure. Reznor himself has stated he plans to continue making music, and that he is merely tired of touring as a large band. Usually when a band declares their latest tour as their “farewell,” it’s total bullshit, but Reznor isn’t your average rock star, and is genuine enough to stick to his declarative statements. I could see him doing a more low-key sort of thing. Perhaps just him and Robin Finck, playing the band’s more quiet / instrumental songs. Either way, I’m excited to see what the man will do next.
SETLIST:
Mr. Self Destruct
Piggy
Heresy
March of the Pigs
Closer
Ruiner
The Becoming
I Do Not Want This
Big Man With a Gun
A Warm Place
Eraser
Reptile
The Downward Spiral
Hurt
1,000,000
Terrible Lie
Metal
Lights in the Sky
Burn
Gave Up
Suck
Physical (You’re So)
The Hand That Feeds
Head Like a Hole